Saturday, February 11, 2006

Religion and freedom and the flag miracle

Reality currently is turning into a painful real satire. Triggered by cartoons. For heaven's sake. C A R T O O N S !!!! I have to check the calender... which year do we have again? Two years ago we celebrated the Kant year in Germany. Does anyone remember him? Immanuel Kant? The guy with the categorical imperative, the Philosopher of the enlightenment? The father of modernity? No? Admittedly... he is not easy to read. Even for me, a not entirely uneducated person, his text require significant thinking. Thinking. Freeing oneself. Wow. And now: A Cartoon "war". ??ß=&§#*+<>-ß?09/%&-:;??$§*!??

Okay... Tolerance. My saying always was: Almost anything can be tolerated, except intolerance. Of course this is more a Zen Koan, than an overly logical statement. The point is to think. Think it over before you judge. But how about the question: Can freedom of religion be granted to a religion that rules out freedom of religion? That brings it down to a more practical problem. My answer is no. My answer always is: religion must remain a private affair. Otherwise we end up in chaos. The separation of church and state is a must. In the US it is already near dead, but in Europe it is still functioning. More or less.

But there is another aspect to the Cartoon Conflict. Those were expressions of *private opinions* in a *private newspaper* which were perfectly legal under the law of Denmark and which are perfectly legal under the laws of all EU states as far as I can tell. Nothing of that was endorsed by any EU Government. And of course a Danish Newspaper has the right to publish whatever they wish in their own country - only the law of their own country is in charge there. Just like nobody has the right to regulate what I privately express in my own house or my own circle of friends. It is outright ridiculous.

During the history of mankind religion and ideology have been one of the main reasons for human suffering. Much of the European population has been wiped out during endless religious conflicts among Christians, although it requires significant mental twists to find anything in the teachings of Jesus Christ that could possibly justify greed and violence. If we are to believe scripture, he never held a sword and wasn't exactly positive about piling up riches. With the old testament it is slightly different - as it is with the Quran. Anyone saying they are only about peace and friendliness and seeking God apparently never read these books. They both are in fact oozing with blood and violence. They both make absolutistic claims. They both justify utmost cruelties under a variety of rather arbitrary conditions and circumstances.

And now Danish Flags are burnt because of cartoons. Cartoons depicting a Mohammed with a bomb on his head (not far fetched since so many self declared martyrs bomb themselves into oblivion, mass murdering others along with them, all allegedly in the name of Allah and Mohammed.) And the Cartoon with Mohammed and the Log in his eye.

It can be historically traced that Religion - and therefore God - are cultural inventions of mankind. And still it is not allowed to talk about the atrocities that are being brought about in the names of established religions. I stress established religions for if I claimed that I act in the name of, say, the Hawaiian Demigod Maui, who talks to me, I would most likely simply be locked away. It therefore seems that it is acceptable to behave in an utterly implausible way if there only are enough people who also do the same!

But it is not that easy. It never is. There is a level of reality that escapes out understanding, and there spirituality has its place. But in the moment where spirituality serves as an excuse for violence against others, something went wrong in the mind of the believer. Even in Islam, a religion brought about by a warrior prophet, the highest form of holy war is the war against self delusion. People should keep that in mind before they fall into religious psychosis and call for the destruction of a little country that many demonstrators in Afghanistan probably cannot even locate on the map. Makes me think: where actually did demonstrators in Afghanistan, Gaza, Syria, Lebanon, Egypt, Indonesia suddenly obtain all those Danish Flags? I am living in the middle of the EU, and I would not have an inkling where I could spontaneously buy a Danish flag...

4 comments:

  1. I think you could order a Danish flag on ebay, but by the time it gets to you, all the fuss would have dissapeared. Blogging may yet become the world religion where free speech and thinking is allowed. This blue planet may yet save itself as it expands (it will get colder).

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi,

    well - I am not sure if you could order anything from ebay while you are in Afghanistan...

    I don't see blogging as the world religion - money might be that, for it is the one belief that is almost all penetrating. People do not even realize anymore that money is an invention.

    Blogging is akin to a sanctuary for free speach, but like with all sanctuaries, it is of very limited importance. The freedom of speech in the blog world is comparable to the survival of animals in a zoo. It survives, but in a gloriously diluted way rendering it near meaningless. You can say what you want, but almost nobody listens, and everyone can find confirmation of any opinion and every world view that suits them. And at the same time nothing is really veryfiable. This tremendous plurality of course also can have positive effects: in the very moment where we allow it to make us think, to reconsider our own assessments and abstain from absolute beliefs, for absolute belief is a property of our own fallible mind and hence is prone to be fallible itself.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I found this on ebay “Show your support for FREE SPEECH by showing support for the country of DENMARK. BUY IT NOW PRICE: $10.95” and of course ship worldwide (Afghanistan) not specified. The point is, you can order anything on ebay for 1cent and pay $100 for shipping anywhere!

    Where was Christianity 2,500 years ago? I don’t think that people of the future (2,500yrs) may not want to be intruded on. Maybe the only form of communication would be “Blogging” hence religion. Back then, Napoleon would have been happy with just a squard of the typhoon class Eurofighter jets.

    Money is already a world religion; “cash is king and long may he reign” is the slogan of a London city brokerage! You have to worship money as your religion or no job! The same way, over a period, people will always look for something to fill the void. Hail Blog!

    Our fallibility is the very essence of life where in order to go forward; we either just stop or regress. But, hey, life goes on tick tuck ticks our biological clock and fine wine matures. We must learn to make time to just leave it all and slow down. Watch the passing of time and think some more.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Yeah, well - I hope blogging will not be the only form of communication 2500 years from now. If the Peak oil pessimists are right, though, smoke signs, jungle drums and the pony express most likely will have seen a revival long before that time. The two things that have been around 2500 years ago were books and letters. And they are still there, in various formats, blogging and emails being among them. But basically that is just a matter of the medium. I believe symbolic communication (writing) will not die out soon. But blogging itself is a bit unpersonal. I generally prefer personal emails, but I also see the tendency of increased "Cocooning" of people. Whcih reminds me (speaking of 2500 years ago) of the goold old Lao Tzu, who predicted something along the lines that in the far future people will know everything about the world but never leave their village.

    Money. I am afraid I cannot embrace it as my religion. Because I know it is not true. It is fake. The reasons why I am fascinated by Buddhism and Taoism (again: speaking of 2500 years ago) is that they rigorously demand to think and search for oneself. Yet I am neither a Buddhist or a Taoist.

    The little detail about the flags.. sure. You are right. But it was interesting anyway that the flags were available in widely apart locations at the same time, my point being that it all looks a bit orchestrated.

    Fine wine and watching time... that reminds me of my writing retreats in Southern France. Long, long, long ago...

    Cheers from Westfalia

    ReplyDelete